Your Training Certificate Cannot Be Compared to Anything, Which Is the Problem

By Oli Huggins

Think about what a completion certificate actually tells you when an employee puts one in front of you. It tells you they finished a course. It does not tell you how well, it does not tell you how they compare to the last person who did the same course, and it certainly does not let you line up 2 candidates and see which one is stronger. The certificate is a signal with no scale behind it, which makes it almost useless for the one thing a manager needs it for, which is judging whether someone can actually do the job and how they stack up against the alternative.

Compare that to any field that has got measurement right. A timed race, a graded exam with a known standard, a competitive ranking, all of these produce a signal you can compare, because everyone was measured against the same fixed bar. You can tell, instantly and credibly, who is stronger, because the result means the same thing for everyone who holds it. Most workplace learning has nothing like this. It produces certificates that confirm attendance and stop there, with no common standard underneath them, which is why 2 people can hold the same qualification and be wildly different in what they can actually do.

For employers in the South West and anywhere outside the deepest talent markets, this gap is expensive, because you are making hiring and promotion decisions on signals that cannot be compared, which means you are guessing. AI makes the point sharper. It has made the content and the certificates trivially easy to produce, so the supply of incomparable signals is now effectively infinite, while the thing that was always scarce, a comparable proof of capability measured against a common standard, has become more valuable precisely because everything around it has been commoditised.

This is the principle ExpertEdge is built on. We turn books from expert publishers into courses designed to produce a comparable, verified signal of what a learner can do, not just a certificate that they turned up, on the view that content is now commodity and a signal you can actually compare is the durable asset.

The practical move for any business this year is to stop accepting certificates that cannot be ranked against anything, and start asking, of every course your people take, whether the thing they hold at the end lets you compare them to someone who holds the same thing. If it does not, it is decoration, not evidence.

Oli Huggins is CEO of ExpertEdge (expertedge.org).